Posted in
church by David Ryle on 11/24/2009
We are, each of us, the inheritors of heresy.
Every child, woman and man is the beneficiary of a prize won through countless demonstrations of heretical heroics and the daring exploits of truth-loving rebels who broke away and ventured out from the flock of accepted ideas, who willingly endured shame, punishment and death for the sake of a truth others held to be false. Our forbears, our Great Ones have always been those who struck out, alone (for a time) to lead us in that great desert-parade into the Unknown, the Other-Than.
The better part of our present understanding, knowledge and wisdom is hand-me-down heresy. It is a robe of many colors, custom-made by generations of heretic-tailors, each adding some new color, some new hue, some new pattern which was not only considered unfashionable at the time, but the damnable ruination of the entire garment.
Those things we hold to be true, which we consider to be self-evident, are accepted as orthodox because that is how they are presented to us. They are seldom appreciated for the acts and words of defiance once required to purchase them. Taking them for granted, we handle lightly many ideas and understandings that were bought with blood and refined in the flames.
We all like to think we are the standard-bearers of a timeless, unchanging Truth. But we aren't. We are the heirs of heresy. No one who says the Earth is round can deny it. No Protestant; no Catholic; no Christian; no Muslim; no Jew; no child of Abraham- who left all that he knew, including the gods of his own family, the god of his limited understanding, to venture out into the Great Beyond of Life with God- no descendant of his could say otherwise. It would be very difficult to give a full estimation of just how much you and I benefit from what once was considered wrong, erroneous, false, misleading or in any other ways heretical.
So, here we are. And here is the question: have we reached the end of understanding? The limit of knowledge? Can we define God? Or is there more to be revealed? If so, is there any way for us to break out of the accepted norms of our limited understanding without the aid of heresy? I don't think so. Do you hate me for saying so? Will you burn me at the stake for suggesting it?
I have ideas of a God Who transcends all of my previous notions. I have a suspicion that if I revealed what I know in my heart to be true, my dear friends would make quick work of readying the furnace. There is something at work in the world, a hunger and a thirst that will tease the truth from your lips and then lovingly drive nails through your hands and your feet.
But I am unafraid. I am happy with my heresy, though slow to speak on it. It needs to ripen on the vine before it is crushed and the seed falls into the ground to die. And you have your truth, too, you heretic.
Will you be faithful to it? Will you be a witness? Will I?
David lives and serves at New Jerusalem Now, a spiritual recovery community in Philadelphia, where he cultivates friendship, garden vegetables, and the occasional heresy.
So the definition of heresy in this article is not "deviation from the central truths of the Bible", but
"[the breaking away and venturing out] from the flock of accepted ideas"
and the espousing of
"what once was considered wrong, erroneous, false, misleading or in any other ways heretical."
So taking your definition of heresy (the breaking away from accepted ideas) at face value, would you say that the heresies of the Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, and Eastern Lightning (cult of China) have also changed the world for the better?
If not, then what are the Biblical truths from which these three cults deviate?
Also, I'd love to know what you would tell me if I had been stabbed, had just minutes to live, and was begging you to tell me how I could find peace with God.
The answer to that question might just reveal what Biblical truths you really do think are obvious, non-negociable, and non-heretical.
Or it might reveal that you are standing on shifting sands when it comes to the most important truth of all.
If we define heresy as "adhering to what was revealed by Yahweh and received by the ekklesia," then Abraham wouldn't be a heretic, since he was following God. He was only a heretic in the Chaldean religion.
In the Christian era, heresies have usually been around the nature of man or God, or the person of Christ. If the Bible reveals Jesus as God, or that grace is needed to know God, then to go against that would not be beneficial, unless saying untrue things about God is beneficial.
And Eugene, I think we just agreed on something...
When I read this, I hear the spirit in which David wrote it. I hear him saying that we shouldn't be so quick to dismiss varying opinions on God, just because they don't line up with our preconceived notions of the divine or our particular religion's doctrine. After all, as a Christian, have I nothing to learn from Muslims or Jews, Buddhists even? Consenting to such a reality doesn't minimize the completeness of the revelation of the truth in Jesus Christ, nor does it mean that I am forsaking my own faith.
This is just a manifestation of grace in our lives. Even theologians can agree on this: they call it "general revelation." I think all followers of Christ should become better students of people with whom they disagree. I think God wants to teach us something thru challenging conversations, like this one. And I'd like to think that Wrecked could be one of those places.
That being, I'm not advocating for theological universalism or relativism. I realize that there are slippery slopes in being completely "open-minded." I realize that some may read this and get the wrong idea; others may be offended. And I understand how some may think this whole conversation is un-edifying. But these are just words, friends. What happens afterward -- how we react to each other, how we give each other grace, and how we lovingly correct one another in our misguided views of God is when we have a chance to edify one another.
I hope we do.
We are all heretics in our own way, because no one can truly know the capital "T" truth of God. Committing "heresy" is merely escaping the manmade conceptions and theology we have set up to more clearly define an undefinable God.
Well-behaved people rarely make the history books......
Add Your comments:
Use this form only to comment on the article that you just read.
If you have a question, please click here to use the Contact form instead. Thanks!